Skip to main content
All editions

The Index Didn't Move. 29 of 52 DAOs Didn't Either.

Mario Semper

The median DAO in our tracked set scores 0.55 out of 10 on delegate engagement. Not 5.5. Zero point five five. That number did not move this week, and neither did the index it sits inside.

The Composite

The DGI Composite closed at 5.84 on 25 October, against 5.85 a week earlier — a change too small to survive rounding. The headline reads as stability.

It is not stability. Of the 52 DAOs that qualified at both reference dates, 23 registered any change at all. The remaining 29 returned an identical score two weeks running. The index held flat because most of it is standing still.

By category:

CategoryDAOsCompositeWoW
Infrastructure85.91+0.25
Social65.87+0.02
DeFi345.86-0.07
Public Goods45.54-0.01

Infrastructure's entire quarter-point gain comes from two DAOs. Arbitrum and ENS between them contribute +0.25 across an eight-DAO group. Remove those two and the category is flat as well.

Movers

Arbitrum +1.62 to 7.73 and takes the top spot. Its DEI of 8.14 is the second-highest in the set, and that component is what carried the score — its HPR was already 9.94 a week ago. One caveat the weekly number hides: Arbitrum's 30-day delta is only +0.57. It sat at 7.16 a month ago, fell to 6.11, and has now climbed back past where it started. This is a recovery, not a breakout.

Convex Finance +0.52 to 6.88, and the strongest 30-day gainer in the set at +1.21. Unlike Arbitrum, Convex has been climbing steadily rather than retracing.

ENS +0.36 to 6.06, on a DEI of 0.83 — meaning the move came from concentration and grassroots participation, not from delegates.

On the way down: Compound -0.49 to 6.05, StakeDAO -0.40, Uniswap -0.37 to 5.58. Uniswap is down -0.94 over thirty days and now sits below the composite average — a DAO with one of the largest treasuries in the space, scoring below the median of a set that includes Bent Finance and Octan.

The sharpest 30-day decline belongs to Lido at -1.24, followed by Aavegotchi at -1.02.

The Index Has One Moving Part

Look at what actually varies across the four components.

HPR — the share of real humans behind the voting wallets — has a median of 10.00 and a full range of 9.56 to 10.00. Across 52 DAOs, half a point separates the best from the worst. PDI and GPI cluster at the neutral midpoint: 30 of 52 DAOs score precisely 5.00 on PDI, and 19 score precisely 5.00 on GPI.

DEI spans 0.05 to 8.75. The ten highest-ranked DAOs average 4.44. The other 42 average 0.80.

So the leaderboard is, in practice, a delegate-attendance ranking wearing a composite's clothes. Everything else is saturated or parked at neutral, and the ordering you see is very nearly the DEI column sorted descending.

Two readings of that, and we will not pretend to be neutral between them.

The first is about DAOs: sybil resistance has stopped being the thing that separates them. The wallets in this set are overwhelmingly human — that question is settled. What is not settled is whether anyone holding delegated power turns up to use it. A DAO can post a near-perfect HPR and still be governed by nobody, and 29 of these 52 produced so little governance activity this week that the index could not detect a change.

The second is about the index itself, and it is the less comfortable one. When 30 DAOs land on exactly 5.00 for a component, that is not 30 organisations sitting at identical, perfectly neutral power concentration. That is the index declining to say anything about them. A neutral default and a measured midpoint look the same in a table and mean opposite things. We would rather name that in public than let a composite average quietly launder it — the methodology page spells out where each component's coverage ends.

Which is the point. Most governance dashboards count votes and stop there. We count who is actually behind them, and we say so when the answer is that nobody is.

Leaderboard — All 52 Qualifying DAOs

#DAOCategoryGVSHPRDEIPDIGPIWoW30d
1ArbitrumInfrastructure7.739.948.145.945.15+1.62+0.57
2WormholeDeFi7.6910.008.755.005.000.000.00
3GearboxDeFi7.0110.006.844.764.23-0.31+0.90
4BalancerDeFi6.8910.003.465.347.27-0.07-0.92
5Convex FinanceDeFi6.8810.005.224.915.44+0.52+1.21
6AavegotchiSocial6.5210.001.046.537.28+0.14-1.02
7Aave DAODeFi6.3810.005.233.444.42-0.01-0.08
8DecentralandSocial6.2610.002.534.675.99+0.05+0.12
9GnosisDAODeFi6.2610.002.064.826.41-0.07-0.35
10SuperfluidDeFi6.2310.001.175.476.71-0.19-0.17
11ShapeShiftDeFi6.1610.002.786.193.63-0.07-0.66
12ENSInfrastructure6.0610.000.835.346.41+0.36-0.24
13CompoundDeFi6.0510.003.973.034.74-0.49-0.85
14Frax FinanceDeFi6.0110.002.412.367.19-0.24-0.27
15ParallelDeFi6.0010.003.604.733.290.00-0.31
16StakeDAODeFi5.9910.001.934.265.79-0.40-0.95
17Redbelly NetworkDeFi5.8010.000.635.005.73-0.10-0.37
181inch NetworkDeFi5.7910.001.754.654.59-0.23-0.21
19BottoSocial5.6810.001.275.304.02-0.05-0.11
20OptimismInfrastructure5.679.850.905.005.000.000.00
21Bent FinanceSocial5.6610.000.645.005.000.000.00
22PancakeSwapDeFi5.6510.000.175.005.55+0.06+0.06
23OctanPublic Goods5.6110.000.435.005.000.000.00
24MantleInfrastructure5.599.870.335.005.270.000.00
25BanklessDAOSocial5.5910.000.385.005.000.000.00
26Hop ProtocolInfrastructure5.599.920.485.005.000.000.00
27GivethPublic Goods5.5810.000.425.004.850.00-0.01
28UniswapDeFi5.5810.001.603.894.51-0.37-0.94
29Rocket PoolDeFi5.5810.000.665.004.590.00-0.02
30Euler FinanceDeFi5.5710.000.305.005.000.000.00
31Index CoopDeFi5.5710.000.295.005.000.000.00
32Across DAOInfrastructure5.5610.000.265.005.000.00-0.21
33Radiant CapitalDeFi5.5610.000.235.005.000.000.00
34KlimaDAOPublic Goods5.5610.000.245.005.000.000.00
35LidoDeFi5.5610.001.823.624.42-0.19-1.24
36Angle ProtocolDeFi5.5510.000.205.005.000.000.00
37SafeInfrastructure5.559.990.545.004.610.00-0.25
38PoolTogetherDeFi5.559.980.255.005.000.000.00
39NounsDAOSocial5.5310.000.105.005.000.000.00
40ApeCoinDeFi5.539.870.305.005.000.000.00
41Stargate / LayerZeroInfrastructure5.529.760.445.005.000.000.00
42dYdXDeFi5.5210.000.085.005.000.000.00
43Curve FinanceDeFi5.5110.000.055.005.000.000.00
44SushiSwapDeFi5.489.950.135.004.810.000.00
45BancorDeFi5.4410.000.445.004.160.000.00
46AlchemixDeFi5.4310.000.385.004.170.00-0.01
47AladdinDAODeFi5.4210.000.365.004.170.00-0.07
48GitcoinPublic Goods5.429.820.584.344.84-0.040.00
49Yearn FinanceDeFi5.429.560.295.005.000.000.00
50Olympus DAODeFi5.3910.000.235.004.170.00-0.09
51CoW DAODeFi5.339.880.483.904.88+0.20-0.13
52MorphoDeFi5.2910.000.563.654.58-0.34-0.66

Check Any DAO Yourself

Run a free governance check on any DAO in the set — HPR, DEI, PDI and GPI, no account needed: chainsights.one/check

Need the full history, all 52 DAOs and every weekly snapshot inside your own stack? The ChainSights API serves exactly the data this post is built on: chainsights.one/api

Methodology

The GVS weights Human Participation Rate at 35%, Delegate Engagement Index at 25%, Power Dynamics Index at 20% and Grassroots Participation Index at 20%. The DGI Composite is the equal-weighted average of GVS across all qualifying DAOs — 52 this week, measured at 25 October against 18 October, counting only DAOs with data at both reference dates. Full methodology at chainsights.one/methodology.

Get DGI Weekly in your inbox

One email a week: DGI Composite moves, category indices, top movers, and what to watch next.

We'll send a confirmation email first (double opt-in). Unsubscribe anytime.