Skip to main content
All editions

Compound Fell 43 Places In Seven Days. The Index Moved 0.02.

Mario Semper

Last week Compound ranked ninth of the 52 DAOs we track. This week it ranks 52nd. Over the same seven days the DGI Composite moved from 5.81 to 5.80.

The Composite

The DGI Composite closed at 5.80 on 8 November, down 0.02 from 5.81 a week earlier. That is the third consecutive week the index has moved by less than 0.04. Across three weeks it has gone 5.84, 5.81, 5.80 — a total drift of 0.04 points.

Of the 52 DAOs with data at both reference dates, 23 moved and 29 returned an identical score two weeks running.

By category:

CategoryDAOsCompositeWoW
Infrastructure85.87-0.01
Social65.84+0.01
DeFi345.80-0.02
Public Goods45.54-0.06

Public Goods is the weakest category and the whole decline is one DAO: Giveth at -0.24 across a four-DAO group contributes -0.06. The other three were flat. We will come back to how Giveth lost those 0.24 points, because it is the most interesting data-quality finding of the week.

Movers

Compound -1.32 to 4.96, ninth place to last. DEI collapsed from 5.15 to 0.48, which accounts for -1.17 of the move at the GVS weight of 25%. HPR fell from 10.00 to 9.48, contributing another -0.18. Compound is the only DAO in the set whose HPR moved at all this week, and 9.48 is now the lowest Human Participation Rate we track. It is the first mover in this series whose score fell on two independent dimensions at once: fewer delegates voting, and a measurably smaller share of real humans behind the wallets that did.

Gearbox -1.22 to 5.93, third place to fourteenth. Last week's edition singled out Gearbox as the only DAO in the top ten whose climb looked structural rather than weekly. That was wrong, and it took seven days to find out. DEI fell from 6.60 to 2.44 and PDI from 5.77 to 4.88. Over thirty days Gearbox now stands at -1.44, more than erasing the +1.21 that made it look structural in the first place.

Parallel +1.52 to 7.23, nineteenth to third — the largest single-week gain we have published. DEI went from 3.49 to 8.50 and carries +1.25 of the +1.52 on its own. Parallel is also the best 30-day performer in the set at +1.24, which means the entire month happened in the last seven days of it.

Lido +0.40 to 6.00, twenty-fifth to thirteenth, driven mostly by PDI rising from 3.77 to 5.16.

Wormhole holds first place at 7.69 and has not moved in thirty days. Arbitrum -0.29 to 7.29 stays second on a DEI slip from 8.08 to 6.97.

And last week's casualty did not come back. Convex Finance lost 1.80 points seven days ago and closed this week at 5.07, down another 0.01. The collapse held. Compound simply fell past it.

The Index Is Stable. The Leaderboard Is Not.

Three weeks, four hundredths of a point. If you read only the composite you would conclude that DAO governance had an uneventful October.

In those same three weeks: last place changed hands twice, three DAOs moved more than a full point, Parallel climbed sixteen positions, Compound fell forty-three, and the DAO we described as structurally improving gave back a month in a week. The composite did not hide this by accident. It is an equal-weighted average over 52 names, so a 1.32-point collapse arrives as -0.025 and a 1.52-point surge cancels it out. Twenty-three signals net to almost nothing and twenty-nine non-signals dilute what survives.

So the composite is the least informative number in this post, and we publish it first anyway, because the alternative is reporting only the churn — and then nobody can tell whether the churn nets out positive or negative. Read it as a floor check, not as news. The news is in the deltas.

Look at where the variance actually lives. HPR spans 9.48 to 10.00 across all 52 DAOs, with a median of exactly 10.00; it moved on precisely one DAO this week. DEI spans 0.05 to 8.75 with a median of 0.49, and 35 of 52 DAOs score below 1.00. The top ten average a DEI of 4.50; the other 42 average 0.62. Every mover above decomposes into DEI and PDI. In practice this leaderboard ranks delegate attendance, and attendance is revocable weekly without anyone announcing anything.

Which is the whole argument against quarterly governance ratings, and also against trusting a single week of ours. We called Gearbox structural on 1 November because it had climbed for a month. One week of data cannot distinguish a structural improvement from a quiet stretch, and anyone whose governance score claims otherwise is selling a rating rather than reporting a measurement. We publish weekly and leave the deltas visible so you can watch us be wrong inside seven days instead of inside a quarter.

The 5.00 Problem, Third Week Running

28 of 52 DAOs score exactly 5.00 on PDI and 20 score exactly 5.00 on GPI — the same 20 on both. Of the 29 DAOs that did not move at all this week, 26 have PDI = 5.00; the three exceptions are Redbelly Network at 4.90, ShapeShift at 4.99 and Gitcoin at 4.29. Fifty-two independent organisations do not land on identical, perfectly neutral power concentration to the second decimal. Our working explanation remains that 5.00 is what the pipeline writes when it has nothing to measure. PDI and GPI are 40% of the GVS, so for more than half the set that 40% is parked on neutral, and the composite is compressed toward 5.5 as a result.

This week sharpened it in both directions. Giveth's PDI fell from 6.19 to exactly 5.00, and that single move is the entire -0.24 and therefore the entire Public Goods decline. Giveth did not drift toward neutral; it landed on it. At the same time Rocket Pool left 5.00 and posted 5.50. So the 5.00 group is not frozen — DAOs enter and leave it week to week, which argues against a one-time default and for a fallback the pipeline writes whenever that week's delegate or holder coverage is missing. A measured midpoint and a shrug look identical in a table, and only one of them belongs in an average.

We would rather print this than let the composite launder it. Read the 5.80 as 23 DAOs that produced a governance signal this week and 29 for which the honest answer is that there was not enough activity to detect one.

Most dashboards count votes and stop there. HPR says the wallets are human; DEI says the humans stopped voting. Those are two different facts about the same DAO, and Compound is this week's proof that they move independently.

Leaderboard — All 52 Qualifying DAOs

#DAOCategoryGVSHPRDEIPDIGPIWoW30d
1WormholeDeFi7.6910.008.755.005.000.000.00
2ArbitrumInfrastructure7.299.946.975.225.14-0.29+0.01
3ParallelDeFi7.2310.008.504.343.68+1.52+1.24
4StakeDAODeFi6.8210.005.404.505.36-0.05-0.11
5BalancerDeFi6.5310.002.624.717.16-0.05-0.86
6Frax FinanceDeFi6.3410.002.414.017.19+0.03-0.16
7SuperfluidDeFi6.3410.001.026.096.83+0.16-0.10
8Aave DAODeFi6.3210.005.043.324.46-0.07-0.06
9DecentralandSocial6.3110.002.365.066.05+0.21+0.16
10ENSInfrastructure6.2610.001.914.996.40+0.22+0.31
11AavegotchiSocial6.2110.000.845.247.25-0.19-0.16
12GnosisDAODeFi6.0310.001.105.056.25-0.20-0.56
13LidoDeFi6.0010.002.395.164.34+0.40+0.15
14GearboxDeFi5.9310.002.444.884.23-1.22-1.44
15UniswapDeFi5.7910.002.024.494.42+0.08-0.16
16Redbelly NetworkDeFi5.7810.000.634.905.730.00-0.19
17ShapeShiftDeFi5.7710.002.284.993.530.00-0.45
181inch NetworkDeFi5.7110.001.414.654.65-0.01-0.19
19BottoSocial5.7110.001.205.524.02+0.06-0.06
20Rocket PoolDeFi5.6810.000.635.504.59+0.10-0.01
21OptimismInfrastructure5.679.850.905.005.000.000.00
22Bent FinanceSocial5.6610.000.645.005.000.000.00
23PancakeSwapDeFi5.6510.000.175.005.550.00+0.06
24OctanPublic Goods5.6110.000.435.005.000.000.00
25Hop ProtocolInfrastructure5.599.920.485.005.000.000.00
26BanklessDAOSocial5.5910.000.385.005.000.000.00
27Euler FinanceDeFi5.5710.000.305.005.000.000.00
28GivethPublic Goods5.5710.000.405.004.85-0.24-0.01
29Index CoopDeFi5.5710.000.295.005.000.000.00
30Across DAOInfrastructure5.5610.000.265.005.000.000.00
31Radiant CapitalDeFi5.5610.000.235.005.000.000.00
32KlimaDAOPublic Goods5.5610.000.245.005.000.000.00
33Angle ProtocolDeFi5.5510.000.205.005.000.000.00
34SafeInfrastructure5.559.990.515.004.610.000.00
35PoolTogetherDeFi5.559.980.255.005.000.000.00
36MantleInfrastructure5.549.870.335.005.000.00-0.05
37NounsDAOSocial5.5310.000.105.005.000.000.00
38ApeCoinDeFi5.539.870.305.005.000.000.00
39Stargate / LayerZeroInfrastructure5.529.760.445.005.000.000.00
40dYdXDeFi5.5210.000.085.005.000.000.00
41Curve FinanceDeFi5.5110.000.055.005.000.000.00
42BancorDeFi5.5010.000.445.004.45+0.06+0.06
43SushiSwapDeFi5.489.950.135.004.810.000.00
44AlchemixDeFi5.4310.000.385.004.170.00-0.01
45AladdinDAODeFi5.4210.000.365.004.170.00-0.07
46GitcoinPublic Goods5.429.820.584.294.880.00-0.01
47Yearn FinanceDeFi5.429.560.295.005.000.000.00
48Olympus DAODeFi5.3910.000.235.004.170.000.00
49CoW DAODeFi5.369.870.574.174.63+0.06+0.01
50MorphoDeFi5.2910.000.563.654.58-0.16-0.59
51Convex FinanceDeFi5.0710.000.212.185.42-0.01-0.19
52CompoundDeFi4.969.480.482.754.84-1.32-1.35

Check Any DAO Yourself

Run a free governance check on any DAO in the set — HPR, DEI, PDI and GPI, no account needed: chainsights.one/check

Need the full history, all 52 DAOs and every weekly snapshot inside your own stack? The ChainSights API serves exactly the data this post is built on: chainsights.one/api

Methodology

The GVS weights Human Participation Rate at 35%, Delegate Engagement Index at 25%, Power Dynamics Index at 20% and Grassroots Participation Index at 20%. The DGI Composite is the equal-weighted average of GVS across all qualifying DAOs — 52 this week, measured at 8 November against 1 November, counting only DAOs with data at both reference dates. Full methodology at chainsights.one/methodology.

Get DGI Weekly in your inbox

One email a week: DGI Composite moves, category indices, top movers, and what to watch next.

We'll send a confirmation email first (double opt-in). Unsubscribe anytime.